Protecting Your Rights Against Theft Charges

Aggressive Defense for Theft and Property Crimes

A theft charge can impact your freedom, employment opportunities, and reputation. Indiana law classifies theft offenses as misdemeanors or felonies, depending on the value of the stolen property and the circumstances of the case. At Blankenship Law, we analyze the prosecution’s evidence, challenge weak accusations, and fight for case dismissals or reduced penalties.

Get in touch
A black and white silhouette of a judge 's gavel on a white background.

Theft charges depend on property value: amounts over $750 result in felony charges.

A black and white icon of a badge on a white background.

Intent matters: misunderstanding or mistaken identity can be a strong defense.

A silhouette of a hat and mask on a white background.

Shoplifting can carry serious penalties: even first-time offenses can lead to jail time.

A black and white icon of a pencil and a piece of paper.

Expungement may be possible: some theft convictions can be removed from your record.

The capitol building in washington d.c. is surrounded by trees on a sunny day.

How We Defend Theft Crime Cases

Challenging Evidence and Fighting for Your Future


Theft cases often rely on surveillance footage, eyewitness testimony, or circumstantial evidence, all of which can be flawed or misinterpreted. We thoroughly investigate the validity of evidence, police reports, and witness statements to uncover weaknesses in the case. Learn about defense strategies.

Many theft charges arise from misunderstandings, financial hardship, or coercion, and the penalties can be severe. We negotiate with prosecutors to seek diversion programs, reduced charges, or case dismissals, especially for first-time offenders. Read more about alternatives to jail.


For felony theft charges, we challenge intent, ownership disputes, and overcharging by prosecutors. We build a custom defense strategy, ensuring your rights are protected at every stage. Contact us for a case evaluation.

60%

Shoplifting accounts for over 60% of theft arrests in the U.S.


Source: National Association for Shoplifting Prevention

$750

Felony theft threshold is $750 in Indiana—amounts below are misdemeanors.


Source: Indiana State Legislature

30% of wrongful theft convictions involve mistaken identity.


Source: Innocence Project

30%

Theft Crimes FAQs

Contact Us

  • What qualifies as theft under the law?

    Theft is defined as taking someone else’s property without permission and with intent to keep it. This includes shoplifting, auto theft, fraud, and embezzlement. The severity of the charge depends on the value and circumstances of the crime.

  • Can a theft charge be reduced or dismissed?

    Yes. If there’s insufficient evidence, lack of intent, or a legal violation during your arrest, charges may be dropped or reduced. Diversion programs and plea deals are also possible for first-time offenders.

  • What is the penalty for a theft conviction?

    Misdemeanor theft convictions can result in up to one year in jail and a $5,000 fine. Felony theft can lead to up to six years in prison, with longer sentences for higher-value property.

  • Will a theft charge stay on my record?

    Yes, but some theft convictions can be expunged after five years for misdemeanors and eight years for felonies. Expungement removes public access to your record, helping restore employment and housing opportunities.

  • How can an attorney help fight a theft charge?

    We challenge evidence, intent, and procedural mistakes, working to get charges reduced, dismissed, or resolved through alternative sentencing. Having an experienced defense lawyer increases your chances of a favorable outcome.

You deserve the power of great counsel.